2:10: Next question: What spending cuts are needed?
On Fox News they’re showing Frank Luntz’s focus group dials. Ron Paul talking about closing military bases made those lines drop like a rock.
2:20: Next question: Who’s hurt the most by our taxes?
Fred wants to be in Mitt’s situation where he doesn’t have to worry about taxes. He then quipped to Romney, “You’re getting to be a good actor.”
2:26: Next question: What changes should be made with NAFTA?
Fred notes free trade is the backbone of our economy. Fred will fight for fair agreements with other nations to open markets.
2:29: Fred gets 30 seconds of free time. National security is paramount. When our worst enemies are facing us we need serious leadership.
2:32: Next question: Climate change.
Fred isn’t in the mood for “hand shows.” He demanded a moment to actually discuss the issue. The liberal moderator refused to give him time, so he refused to bother with her.
2:51: Next question: What’s the biggest impediment to education?
Fred declares the National Education Association is the biggest obstacle. The teachers union is stopping parents from getting more and better choices to educate their kids.
Let me remind you Mike Huckabee has been endorsed by the New Hampshire NEA.
Tancredo scolded Huckabee for trying to dictate what local schools should teach. Huckabee responded by talking about a bully pulpit.
2:53: Next question: What would you do in your first year as President?
Ron Paul would bring the troops home from Iraq. Luntz’s dialers don’t approve. Fred wouldn’t do that. He wants victory and knows our troops can do that.
Fred says he’d tell the American people the truth about the threats facing our country. He’d tell the public that we have to fix our entitlements and stop judges from getting out of control.
In the comments Brian Walters comments:
Every time Fred speaks the dials go way up!!!!
On the other hand, Huckabee is doing TERRIBLE!!!!
3:09: Next question: Iran and intelligence.
Fred calls it the best question asked today. We’re paying the price for our poor intelligence. We have to rebuild it from the bottom up and get help from other nations. A President can’t let a piece of paper solely determine their decisions.
3:23: The debate ends and the analysis begins. How do you think Fred did?
3:31: Marc Ambinder on Fred’s performance:
Fred Thompson was smart, funny, irascible and consistent, and probably helped his standing here. He even got in a good dig at Romney.
Chuck Todd thought it was a great debate for Fred:
Frankly, the candidate who had the best afternoon I think was Fred Thompson. This was easily his best debate performance and he seemed to shine in this subdued format.
3:35: John Hawkins declares Fred the winner too:
Winner: Fred Thompson. Good substance, good personality, and his I won’t raise my hand for an answer question reminded me of Reagan say “I paid for this microphone.” Fred definitely won.
And add Jim Geraghty to the list:
Winner: Thompson. Don’t know if it will be enough, but he ought to get at least a little bump out of this. The moment he basically told the moderator where she could stick her “show of hands” question – well, I was inspired.
3:44: Philip Klein is another who declared Fred the winner:
Fred Thompson was the only candidate who stood out. He was funny, charming, and peppy. Here was a guy who wasn’t afraid to speak hard truths, and who displayed knowledge of the policy issues–especially on entitlements. But the moment of the debate, the moment that will be talked about should he defy expectations and go on to win the nomination, was when he refused to raise his hand at the behest of the moderator. This demonstrated conviction, showed he was able to stand up for his principles, that he was a man who valued substance, a leader rather than a follower, and somebody who is running a different kind of campaign. In short, today Thompson was everything that conservatives had hoped they’d be getting when he announced his candidacy.
And From Right Wing News:
2:08: Fred hit entitlements. Nice, but not splashy.
2:09: Being able to watch the focus group numbers while they talk is pretty neat. I like that feature, which I’m getting on Fox.
2:09: Decent answer from Mitt.
2:10: Huckabee’s answer is mildly disturbing because it suggests he wants to make us self-sufficient.
2:10: McCain will make us oil independent in 5 years? That’s complete and utter bunk.
2:18: Fred is so right about Social Security and Medicare. I like his answer. Bam. No, Warren Buffet, we can’t take care of their Medicare.
2:20: Fair tax, which Huckabee is relentlessly flogging, is unpassable. So, why talk it up so much?
2:20 Mitt gives the politically correct answer.
2:21: Fred gets the first funny line of the debate off tonight. He’s doing really well.
2:27: McCain is a huge free trader who wants to open markets. Good answer.
2:28: NAFTA from Rudy. Rudy loves and defends it. Good. We do want to embrace a global market. How much can we sell to these people as they come out of poverty? Very good answer from Rudy.
2:29: Fred Thompson: Mexico better think about criticizing us when they realize how good NAFTA has been for them. Too many people close their markets to us. We can’t stand for that. Really good answer.
2:31: Ron Paul is screwing this up. He should be talking resume instead of going on another rant. I am Ron Paul, a former doctor and I served in the military, yada, yada. He wasted his opportunity.
2:38 Rankings so far.
Thompson
Romney
Giuliani
McCain
Hunter
Tancredo
Huckabee
Paul
Keyes
2:50: The good news for Ron Paul tonight: he won’t be giving the worst performance for once.
2:51: Ok, tax credits for teachers, encourage private school, home schooling. Good answer on education.
2:51: Bam! Fred slaps the teacher’s union! Rock on! They bring in millions to fight choice. Inner city people need a chance to have choice. Let’s give choice to everyone. Another really good answer.
Summary: This was a very well run, very serious debate. CNN should ask these people how to run a debate.
Winner: Fred Thompson. Good substance, good personality, and his “I won’t raise my hand for an answer” question reminded me of Reagan saying, “I paid for this microphone.” Fred definitely won.
Top Tier Loser: Mike Huckabee. The fast format appeared to take him off of his game. He was very flat.
Rankings from bottom to top.
Alan Keyes: Came off as mildly nuts.
Ron Paul: Probably happy Keyes was there to make him look more reasonable.
Mike Huckabee: Very flat.
Duncan Hunter: He did Ok.
Tom Tancredo: He gets better every debate.
John McCain: Very average performance from a guy who usually does better.
Rudy Giuliani: Solid, but not spectacular.
Mitt Romney: He got back on his game without the frequent attacks.
Fred Thompson: His best performance yet.
Check how high the lines go on the charts as Fred Talks:
[youtube QnOvU1TsT3g nolink]
[youtube bksBYmqrpng nolink]
[youtube yUn8GSbUl_4 nolink]